At 309 Fairidge Drive in Cedarwood, a brick two-story home with four bedrooms, three full baths and 2,762 square feet sits on a lot of about six-tenths of an acre. It is listed at $399,000 with no HOA, and the listing points out that Cedarwood Swim and Tennis Club is nearby. In Kinsley, the D.R. Horton community off Guilford College Road, a new single-story home at 203 Priam Way in The Villas at Kinsley is listed at $419,000 for 1,797 square feet.
That comes to about $144 a square foot for the Cedarwood home and about $233 for the Villas home. Buyers new to Jamestown often take that gap as the cost of buying new. Mostly it is not. Inside Kinsley, D.R. Horton's two-story homes are priced close to Jamestown's older resale stock. Most of the premium attaches to one-level, lower-maintenance living. This fall, resale sellers and the builder also bargain in different ways, and that matters as much as the sticker price.
The "From" Price Is a Floor, and the Listed Homes Are the Market
Kinsley is the master-planned community D.R. Horton is building on land along Guilford College and Mackay roads. At a March 12 work session, Jamestown Planning Director José Colón described it to the Town Council as roughly 637 single-family homes and 345 townhomes, plus an amenity center and open space. YES! Weekly's Jamestown News coverage of that session also reports plans for about 320 apartments and 40 casitas.
Three sections are selling now, and each one advertises a starting figure:
- The Meadows at Kinsley is listed from $355,000, with four-bedroom, two-story plans from 2,240 square feet.
- The Villas at Kinsley is listed from $379,990, with mainly one-story plans of two or three bedrooms from 1,673 square feet.
- The Preserve at Kinsley is listed from the $409s, with two-story plans of three to five bedrooms from 2,175 square feet.
The individual homes D.R. Horton has listed for sale are priced higher. In mid-November, the homes listed in the Villas ran from $414,000 to $449,000. The Preserve's ran from $426,990 to $464,000. The Meadows stayed closest to its advertised figure, at $355,000 to $374,000. Those listed prices are the right numbers to set against a resale home, because a resale listing is also a finished house at a real price.
Price per Square Foot Shows Where the Premium Sits
The table below shows each home's list price per square foot. These are mid-November list prices on Triad MLS and D.R. Horton's community pages, not closed sales.
| Home | Section or area | Price | Sq. ft. | Per sq. ft. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 203 Priam Way, 1 story | Villas at Kinsley | $419,000 | 1,797 | $233 |
| 309 Sefton Drive, 1 story | Villas at Kinsley | $414,000 | 1,883 | $220 |
| 208 Mary Montrose Blvd., 1.5 story | Villas at Kinsley | $449,000 | 2,422 | $185 |
| 313 Sefton Drive, 1.5 story | Villas at Kinsley | $437,000 | 2,671 | $164 |
| Listed Meadows homes, 2 story | Meadows at Kinsley | $355,000–$374,000 | 2,240–2,439 | about $146–$167 |
| 113 Sagewood Road | Jamestown resale | $369,000 | 1,860 | $198 |
| 6309 Stone Gables Court, pending | Jamestown resale | $450,000 | 2,611 | $172 |
| 309 Fairidge Drive | Cedarwood resale | $399,000 | 2,762 | $144 |
| 112 Royal Road | Jamestown resale | $425,000 | 2,988 | $142 |
A new four-bedroom two-story in the Meadows costs a little more per square foot than a large resale in Cedarwood, and it can cost less than a smaller resale like 113 Sagewood Road. Among two-story family homes, being new carries only a modest premium.
The single-story Villas are where the price per foot climbs past $200. When most of the house is on one floor, the builder puts it on a larger foundation and roof for each finished foot. A smaller floor plan also spreads the kitchen and baths over fewer square feet. If you need to live on one level, you are paying for that layout, and a resale ranch in Jamestown is the comparison worth pricing. With stairs in the picture, you can get a new home in the Meadows for about what the resale market charges.
What the Villas Price Includes, and What Comes Later
D.R. Horton's community features for Kinsley include a clubhouse, pool, walking and nature trails, dog park, fitness space and pickleball. According to the Town of Jamestown's minutes of the March 12, 2026 work session, those amenities belong to Phase 2, along Guilford College Road. The builder said it hoped to start the amenity package the following year, which is 2027, and that it could not give specifics until design and permitting were finished.
A recently sold Villas home on Triad MLS shows a $160 monthly HOA fee. Its description says the fee covers lawn maintenance and amenities. That is one home's figure as of November 2026, so confirm the dues for the exact section and lot you are considering. When you compare costs, a Villas buyer is pricing in someone else mowing the lawn now and a pool and clubhouse later.
Resale homes in Jamestown are not always HOA-free either. In the same November listings, 202 Quarterpath Lane, at $340,000, carries a $269 monthly HOA, and 6309 Stone Gables Court carries $291.50. Cedarwood's Fairidge Drive listing shows none. Add those dues to the monthly payment before you compare two homes on price alone. Our Jamestown townhomes vs. houses guide covers the maintenance tradeoff in more depth.
Resale Sellers Have Room to Move This Fall
The broader Guilford County market changed over the past year. In YES! Weekly's report of the Greensboro Regional REALTORS® Association's third-quarter 2026 figures, the county had 1,423 homes for sale during the third quarter of 2026, up 30.2% from the same quarter of 2025. Months' supply rose from 2.8 to 3.8 over that span, and homes averaged 40 days on market, up from 37. The county's median sale price for the third quarter was $338,820, down 2.9% from $349,000 a year earlier. Greensboro's fell 7.2%, to $320,000.
The association's 2026 president, Bill Warmath, told YES! Weekly that "sellers need to be strategic and price their homes competitively." Those are countywide figures, not Jamestown alone. They still show that a resale seller this fall is competing with more listings than a year ago. A Jamestown resale listed in November is a price you can negotiate, and the per-square-foot figures in the table are likely ceilings rather than final prices. If months of inventory is a new measure for you, our explainer on months of inventory in Greensboro shows how to read it.
The Builder Negotiates Through the Mortgage
D.R. Horton bargains in a different way. Its Kinsley page advertises a 5.50% fixed-rate FHA mortgage, 6.212% APR, on certain homes. The offer applies to contracts signed on or after October 19, 2026 that close on or before November 30, 2026. Buyers must finance through the affiliated lender, DHI Mortgage, to get that rate, though using DHI Mortgage is not required to buy the home. A separate Main Street Stars incentive, worth up to $3,000 toward options for eligible military, law enforcement, firefighter, healthcare and education professionals, requires a contract by November 30 and closing by December 31, 2026.
Both offers require a signed contract by November 30, so they are close to expiring. Builder offers change often, so ask the Kinsley sales office what is posted the week you visit. Right now the builder is competing on monthly payment, while resale sellers in a market with more inventory are competing on price. Treat these figures as general information, not financial advice, and compare any rate offer with a quote from a lender you choose.
Kinsley's pricing has already shifted once this year. In March, the builder described homes as priced in the mid-to-high $400,000s and expected townhomes near $425,000. By November, the Meadows was listing homes in the $350,000s.
Kinsley's Scale Shapes Its Future Resale
With close to a thousand for-sale homes planned, Kinsley will be selling new houses for years. Phase 2 and Phase 6 were in design as of March, and Phase 6 was described as higher-end homes at the back of the site. A Kinsley owner who sells in the next few years could be listing alongside new D.R. Horton homes on nearby streets, possibly with builder rate offers attached. Cedarwood and Jamestown's other established neighborhoods have no builder setting prices next door. Weigh that if you expect to move again within five years.
A Few Common Questions
Which Kinsley section is closest to resale value per square foot? The Meadows, among the homes listed in mid-November. Its four-bedroom two-story homes priced out at roughly $146 to $167 a square foot, within the range of nearby resale listings. Our Jamestown neighborhood page covers the rest of the town.
Is the pool open? The amenity center is planned for Phase 2. The builder said in March 2026 that it hoped to begin it in 2027.
If you are deciding between a new home at Kinsley and a resale nearby, Colleen Long is glad to talk through how Kinsley's listed homes compare with the Jamestown resales on the market that week. If you own a home in Jamestown and want to see where it stands against Kinsley's pricing, let's connect and request your free home valuation.